Melba's New York Yelp Reviews - Melba's New York - Kaufe eine Reservierung
Reservierung bei Melba's New York für Heute oder Morgen? Geht ganz Easy!
Kaufe eine verifizierte reservierung bei Melba's New York von Jemanden der sie nichtmehr braucht.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservierungs!
All listed Reservierungs are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Melba's New York
Melba's New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
56 Reviews
0 Replys |
Made a reservation, arrived and was seated promptly.
Our waitress was amazing, didn't rush us as I wanted to choose wisely. I went with the Signature dish, Chicken and Eggnog Waffle. It was beyond my expectations. The chicken was crispy on the outside and juicy in the inside. Seasoned perfectly. The waffle was so fluffy and the strawberry butter was the perfect compliment. Didn't really need the maple syrup. To highlight our dining experience, the owner, Ms Melba came by to chat. She was down to earth, gracious, and her kindness was appreciated. This Connecticut girl can't wait to visit again. .
Be the first to ReplyListen Linda! Melba's food was amazing.
I ordered the catfish, collard greens and potato salad. Everything was truly perfect, but I seriously got stuck on the potato salad, as it was truly perfect. Tasted like it was out of my mother's kitchen! The servings were hefty and you couldn't eat it all in one sitting. The greens were a little sweet, a little spicy and a little vinegary, which made them a lot yummy! The catfish was fried perfectly and I ate it with no sauce, it didn't need it. We happened to dine in while Melba herself was in the restaurant and what a kind and absolutely sweet woman she is. The art work is amazing! Best food that I enjoyed on this trip to NY. Oh, always get a slice of sweet potato pie - delicious!
Be the first to ReplyFood was delicious service was good just need a bigger
Food was delicious service was good just need a bigger place .Get there early or you will be on line.
Be the first to ReplyI dont typically go for soul food often these days because
I dont typically go for soul food often these days because the weight keeps on climbing, but I am happy that I finally got to try out this harlem staple and I would not mind going back Food: 9/10: It was juicy, the waffle didnt taste like egg nog but it was still delicious. The mac was everything I needed it to be. Overall some solid food. Drinks: 8/10 superrr strong which is good no complaints there, but overall it was too overpowering and you couldnt taste much of anything else. Service 6/10: considering there was barely any people there at the time we arrived service is extremelyyyyy slow my goodness. Our waiter was a sweetheart but seems like she was by herself running around table to table Ambiance: 6/10: This is not a place you go for the aesthetic if you're looking for a birthday restaurant etc, you go there to get your belly full and keep it pushing. But you will not be disappointed!
Be the first to ReplyLoved! First time and it won't be the last.
We had a craving for soul food and this hit the mark! The soul spring rolls were spectacular, the fried chicken crispy, the spinach was fine, although not my fave and the greens had too much sugar for my liking. That didn't however deter from the meal overall! My gf had the oxtails with mac n cheese which she loved! Highly recommend this spot and ask for Kenny! He does not play about his tables. Just go!
Be the first to ReplyThis restaurant is ABSOLUTELY Horrible! Food tastes
This restaurant is ABSOLUTELY Horrible! Food tastes terrible! I don't know what kind of food Melba is serving, but It was disappointing, and it's definitely not the real soul food...It's a bunch of garbage! I would hate to go in that kitchen and see who's cooking back there...Definitely not any real cooks/chefs. I visited NYC second week in April, and couldn't wait to get to Melba's due to all the hype...Will never go there again...NEVER;! I was planning on going into detail about just how awful the food was, and how uninviting and dirty looking the patio entrance to the restaurant was, but I get a nauseous headache just thinking about it. And the one restroom for all the customers is ridiculous...There was another one, but I guess it was for the employees because it was off limits to customers . MELBA, you need to invest the money you're making into revamping your restaurant...Rebuild/remodel...get some new cooks...buy quality food...In fact, you should be ashamed of yourself, and the people who are writing these raving reviews need to STOP IT...STOP MISLEADING PEOPLE...especially Sherri Shepherd! Sherri STOP promoting Melba's....I know she's your friend and all...but, you gotta know that her food is CRAP! WARNING: DON'T GO TO MELBA'S!
Be the first to ReplyThe food and/or drink made me vomit before I could even
The food and/or drink made me vomit before I could even take more than 5 steps outside. I ordered fried chicken, candied yams, and macaroni. Then I ordered a drink as well. The food came early but the drink never came. My table finished our food (and their drinks), and after 25 minutes and two asks, we receive my drink and a note that "the drink is free and was made with extra love". I'm not sure if it was the food, the drink, or a combination of both -- but I feel like this may have been intentional. Especially given how "special" and delayed my drink was. I will NEVER return. Just go to Sylvia's, y'all.
Be the first to ReplyI finally achieved this bucket item.
I think it was Melba herself or maybe a fan that claimed her carrot cake it one of the best in the land. I am sorry to say I had high hopes of this being true. I recently visited NYC taking my great granddaughter on a fun vacation 4/22/2024. My first meal was DoorDash from Melba's we were wore out from the flight. I would have tried more things on the menu but they only let you spend 100.00 with DoorDash delivery, don't get the reasoning. We got 2x oxtails, greens , 2x Mac and Cheese, carrot cake, sweet potato pie, yams and maybe chicken strips not sure about the strips.. Strips and bacon is the only meant my great grand will eat. Ok, here goes I have had much better carrot cake that being said for me the icing had the right amount of nuts just a little sweet, that spot of pineapple was just right not enough nuts in the cake for me and not moist enough, it has the makings of being one of the best. Did not like the thin cut oxtail actually gave most everything to homeless. I liked the Mac and cheese my granddaughter said she needed more seasoning . Loved the yams didn't eat them but I wished that mixture of yams was what she used for the sweet potato pie it needed those yams to be my kind of pie. Now hear this Melba makes the best greens in the world!!!! Those greens are the bomb. All in all her soul food feels like it is from the heart would I go back heck yes. There are many soul food restaurants that don't get it nearly as close as she does. Melba's is a safe experience. Great grand enjoyed American Dream, Bronx Zoo, FAO Swartz and Serendipity oh and the room.
Be the first to ReplyMelba's service was warm kind and quick.
There is a waiting area at the front of the restaurant that is large enough to take your coat and even hold a stroller. The decor is simple and elegant with some great paintings which honor Black culture on the walls. The small bar is cozy and the bar tender is welcoming. Drinks are sweeter than I'd like but if that's your palette you'll enjoy. The food is the real reason to come. Everything was good the oxtails were full of meat not just fate and bone. The Mac and cheese was so crispy on top with tender macaroni and a smooth luxurious cheese béchamel. The yams were the perfect texture though a bit sweet. The collard greens were some of the best I have had in Harlem. The Smothered chicken or fried chicken is excellent; Crispy skin tender meat , seasoned well and balanced. Plus we were served food within 10 mins of ordering. The price is right. For the serving size and quality the price is very affordable. I Recommend for sure.
Be the first to ReplyWe had the traditional chicken and waffles.
Wow! That and the terrific rum punch make Melba's a must visit.
Be the first to ReplyI can't believe I didn't discover this place sooner! What a
I can't believe I didn't discover this place sooner! What a gem! The food is so delicious and flavorful. I ordered crab cakes with yams, Mac and cheese, and collard greens. The collard greens and yams are the best. They have decent sized bar to sit at or tables if you prefer. I didn't order a cocktail but I did have the Melba's skinny margarita. The owner has her own canned margarita!! It was super light but I felt a very nice buzz. It was perfect because I don't like feeling too tipsy and it has delicious flavor. I wish there was way to purchase them in store.
Be the first to ReplyDining at Melba's is always a pleasant experience.
Her chicken and waffles is my go to dish regardless of the time of day!
Be the first to ReplyThis restaurant was by far the most amazing comfort food I
This restaurant was by far the most amazing comfort food I have ever had! The service was exceptional and the ambiance was dazzling. I thought I was going to need a to go box for my left overs but there was nothing left on my plate to take home. Now as I fly back to California I will recall the delicious food that topped my experience in Harlem. The waffle with strawberry butter along with the chicken wings etc. are stuff dreams are made of. Melba's delivered! Between Sylvia's and Melba's if you only have time for one, I'd choose Melba's!
Be the first to ReplyMy four friends and I have been wanting to dine at Melba's
My four friends and I have been wanting to dine at Melba's Harlem Restaurant after hearing positive reviews. The place was quite attractive with beautiful African art work and spacious seating arrangements, although one of our tables was unstable. The staff was hospitable and service was good. We were looking forward to trying Melba's signature chicken and waffles and other soul food. We ordered two entrees of chicken and waffles, a side order of waffles, smothered chicken, short ribs, collard greens and Mac and cheese. The food presentation was good. However, those famous waffles had no taste of eggnog and was not tasty. The serving of syrup was small and we asked for additional syrup. The portion of dark chicken was tiny and my wings were a generous portion, but the chicken did not taste good. The greens were too spicy but the Mac and cheese were good. The order of sweet potato pie was cold. Needless to say, the food was a big disappointment. It's hard for me to believe that Melba beat Bobby Flay with her signature waffles, unless we weren't served the signature waffles. We just should have gone to our local diners where the food far surpassed Melba's. In all, we feel Melba's is far too overrated and we will not be returning.
Be the first to ReplyWe came in on a Friday afternoon after not being able to
We came in on a Friday afternoon after not being able to get in another restaurant. They seated us promptly, and they also were courteous. We ordered fried chicken and oxtails. My sides were yams and greens. The food came out in literally 2mins. I can appreciate that! It was fresh and hot. I didn't try the chicken, but my guy said it was just ok, and he's a chicken head! Eats chicken 10xs a week! Seriously. I had the oxtail meal, which wasn't good. It was little oxtails with tough meat. Drowned in gravy/sauce that wasn't good. I didn't like the hot sauce it was like a spicy thick tarter ketchup type of sauce. I didn't eat it. Wrapped it to go. The greens and yams weren't all that. I wouldn't go back. And I'd say try them for yourself.
Be the first to ReplyFirst time dining here and it didn't disappoint! I went
First time dining here and it didn't disappoint! I went here on a Saturday during lunch time and it was a full house. They were bumping the jams which flowed through every corner of the restaurant. The menu had a lot that I wanted to indulge, but I was disciplined enough to stick to two dishes: Spring Rolls and the Chicken & Eggnog Waffle. The Spring Rolls were vegetarian and had a fried outer layer. More like an egg roll shell than spring roll. The sauce enriches roll! The Chicken & Eggnog Waffle was the main event and I just loved everything about the dish. I opted for white meat and the chicken was satisfyingly crispy. I'm not sure if my palette could differentiate the eggnog, but nonetheless it was a hearty waffle that blended well with the syrup and butter. Service was friendly and welcoming. I'll come back again next time I find myself in Harlem!
Be the first to ReplyI need an option for Half Stars! Lol Melba's was
I need an option for Half Stars! Lol Melba's was recommended over Sylvia's when asking for suggestions. I was looking for more of a brunch spot that offered breakfast items as well; but it does not. We almost passed up the entry, due the outdoor area. The inside is really cool w/pics/portraits of black folks like Marvin Gaye. The music is great and the full bar is in eye shot! We arrived when they first opened a little after 11 and there were only few parties in there at the time; but if was getting full by the time we left, so I know it gets a lot of traffic. We ordered the eggnog waffle w/Catfish, and one with Chic, fried chicken meal w/garlic mash & greens (made with Turkey), and a side of ASAP YAMS. The fried chicken was really good! I honestly was a bit disappointed w/the waffle and catfish. It don't typically like thick waffles b/c they sometimes tend to be doughy; but this was the "signature" dish. They were a bit bland, unfortunately. The fried catfish was not what I am used to. Not sure the batter that was used but, I could've passed and got the chicken instead. The most disappointing dish was the Yams...as my colleague said..."the yams were not yammin!" They were thick and lacked sweetness. Our consensus was that this soul food is not targeted at the demographic that actually eats soul food! Servers were really nice. Parking on street; but not sure how easy it is b/c we took a Lyft.
Be the first to ReplyMelba's exudes an incredible vibe, blending the essence of
Melba's exudes an incredible vibe, blending the essence of Harlem with soulful food delights. Our dining experience included the sumptuous Salmon paired with ASAP yams and Mac and cheese, which my 2-year-old niece devoured with gusto. The chicken was undoubtedly a hit, and the collard greens were fresh and expertly seasoned. For appetizers, the crab cakes and eggrolls were standout "comforts" that truly elevated the experience. The egg roll alone was enough to make me feel like Harlem owed me nothing.
Be the first to ReplyI really wanted to like this restaurant but the lack of
I really wanted to like this restaurant but the lack of service, disorganization and mediocre food would not allow me to give Melba's past a 1 star rating.Story time, we got here past our reservation time so I will take that on the chin but to wait over an hour and a half while there were empty seats approximately 5 tables open, is out of control.Melba HERSELF was there and saw us waiting with open seats in HER restaurant and did nothing about it. SMH she even spoke to us but didn't challenge the hostess who was rude and clearly not properly trained to do her job.Cons:-sweet potato's came from a can-our drinks came out when our meal did -the waitress was friendly but not very attentive (they were not busy)-mac and cheese; more cheese than anything elsePros:-strawberry Hennessy So much potential, poor execution.
Be the first to ReplyVisited NY for a special occasion.
Being from the south I was looking for soul food. The group selected Melba's. I don't know how or who thought this was a great choice for soul food. The food was horrible! HORRIBLE. The potato salad had no flavor, no seasonings. It was potato and mayo. Living in Maryland we asked about the lump crab cakes. The biggest disappointment. Small, flat and breaded. The collard greens full of vinegar - no flavor! Turkey meatloaf was a sliced loaf ordered from somewhere frozen. There were no signs of homemade. Disappointing. The desserts were not homemade and appeared to come from a box. Definitely it was store bought. My friends called it nursing home food for those with a restricted diet. The place was crowded and I didn't understand why. Then to top it off the food was nasty and the bill was $140. The best part of the place is the artwork. Do yourself a favor, save some money and skip this on your next trip to NY.
Be the first to ReplyFantastic soul food!! We got lucky with a last minute
Fantastic soul food!! We got lucky with a last minute reservation and was greeted with warm service and cozy atmosphere upon walking in. To start off, we ordered the Melba's Spring Rolls, which were bursting with flavor and paired well with the sauce on the side. For our mains, my favorite was the Chicken and Waffles. The chicken was perfectly crispy on the outside and juicy on the inside, and the waffles were fluffy and sweet. We also got the BBQ Braised Short Ribs with our choice of collard greens and sweet yam as sides, and it did not disappoint. The meat was tender and falling off the bone, and the BBQ sauce was tangy and sweet. I especially enjoyed the collard greens, which were well-cooked and seasoned, and the sweet yam added a nice contrast to the savory ribs.Overall nice atmosphere and lovely Southern-style dishes!
Be the first to ReplyIt had been years since I'd last been to Melba's, so I was
It had been years since I'd last been to Melba's, so I was so pleasantly surprised to see they had expanded, making the space even larger. This may have been done a while ago, but because I hadn't been, I didn't know. Also, Melba was there, wonderfully greeting her guests and speaking about the restaurant to all who asked her questions.And then the food came (quickly too!). Although I recall her speaking about how she was making cleaner soul food (years ago), I wasn't prepared for HOW clean and HOW delicious it would be. So flavorful, but still soul food. It's proof positive that soul food doesn't need to be drowned in sugar or butter for it to taste exceptional. Masterful is the only word I can think of to describe what I experienced. I absolutely cannot wait to go back.
Be the first to ReplyGreeters were pleasant but not welcoming.
15 minutes to get a drink at a bar with only two other people????? Appetizers arrived lukewarm to cold. Still wondering the name of server since he did not introduce himself. Ambience was very cafeteria. Staff having more fun in the back of the dining area than the patrons. I was very disappointed. Two stars because my guest enjoyed the Oxtails.
Be the first to ReplyWarm, intimate, quality.
Inviting, home cooking with love. VISIT MELBASShe has obviously handled picked her partners. Everyone was welcoming.
Be the first to ReplyI wasn't expecting Melba's to be so good because I am from
I wasn't expecting Melba's to be so good because I am from the south and what northern city can do soul food like the south? I had to eat my words. The food was delicious. Melba's would have received 5 stars; however, if you are going to do soul food then you must have cornbread and Melba's doesn't serve cornbread. Ms. Melba, now you know better. Fly me to NYC and I will show you how to make gluten-free and regular cornbread that will make you dance. I had Salmon, candied yams, and collard greens. I also had a sangria. For dessert, we opted for the sweet potato pie which was delightful. Also, Bryan, our server was so friendly and helpful and he deserves an award for being one of the best servers ever. Please give this man a raise. He went above and beyond to make us happy and he definitely exceeded our expectations. Kudos to Bryan. Lastly, that hot sauce is amazing. I am waiting for it to be bottled and mass produced because I will definitely be ordering some.
Be the first to Reply