Mary's Fish Camp New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Mary's Fish Camp New York - Kaufe eine Reservierung
Reservierung bei Mary's Fish Camp New York für Heute oder Morgen? Geht ganz Easy!
Kaufe eine verifizierte reservierung bei Mary's Fish Camp New York von Jemanden der sie nichtmehr braucht.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservierungs!
All listed Reservierungs are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mary's Fish Camp New York
Mary's Fish Camp New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
11 Reviews
0 Replys |
Waitstaff ruined the experience
Amazing food - as always. But this time an unsettling experience - an exchange initiated by a member of the wait staff toward a customer at another table. She confronted them rather loudly (and rudely) about the amount of the tip they were leaving. In essence she was publicly shaming the customer so the whole restaurant could hear it. (From the customerโs reaction -it did look like there was an honest mistake made with the cash given to her.) Understand the frustrations of wait staff - but not the way you handle this in the service industry. It should have been done in a much more discreet and quieter manner.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing service, outstanding food
Happened across this place by chance, thankfully,had a fantastic warm welcome from the host and the service was just amazing, ordered the IPA which was a really good drink, and oysters to start ,Oysters were so tasty!!!! Had the special which was sea bass and it was cooked to perfection I will certainly come back next time Iโm in NYC and Iโd recommend this place without a doubt
Be the first to ReplyGooooood lobster rolls
We were a group of 3 people, ordered oysters for appetizer - not the best. We also ordered fish and chips, fish tacos, and lobster roll. Fries are amazing, they were so thin but still chewy. lobster roll was amazing, other plates were regular. The fish in fish tacos are the same as the fish and chips. Wine came in a water glass and at the price of 21 USD. Get the lobster roll and nothing more.
Be the first to ReplyExcellent dinner
Fish is my favorite protein and we were not disappointed! I had scallops which were cooked perfectly - hereโs a picture of the delicious shrimp burger. We met Mary herself who was gracious and kind. Weโll have to visit again.
Be the first to ReplyDowntrodden & Fall Downhill Fast
I was so disappointed to see how far downhill this restaurant has gone downhill over the years. It used to be one of my favorite places in the neighborhood. The service was not accommodating and the cook would not even filet the whole fish that I ordered. The cooks were banging pots and dishes and there were only 4 tables seated. I can only imaging the noise level if the place were packed. Also, the amount of smoke that filtered into the dining area from the open kitchen made my eyes water. It was a terrible dining experience. It was awful and sad to see the place fall so low.
Be the first to ReplyBest Lobster Roll in town!
This was my first stop when I got to NY. Saw it through someoneโs Instagram. Boy, was I surprised! I had eaten many lobster rolls but this was the best! Their fries are good too!
Be the first to ReplyGreat seafood in a small space
Itโs a great lunch. But I would consider it spendy. The lobster roll is excellent although I think the buns could be better. The oysters are fresh and corn chowder was excellent. Alcohol was expensive and the wine list was very small. The food was fresh and inviting. My wife loved it.
Be the first to ReplyNever disappoints
We make a point of going to Mary's whenever we are in NYC and have always had a great experience and fantastic, fresh seafood. Went for late lunch on recent visit and it was mostly locals. Lobster roll as good as always and my husbands grilled whole fish was perfectly cooked and nicely presented. Service is always friendly and good. You can't go wrong here.
Be the first to ReplyFresh and delicious seafood
Although this place is very small and sometimes the wait is over an hour, it is worth the wait! The best seafood in New York City! It's definitely not a romantic or cozy place to go for an intimate dinner. But you will get attentive service and a delicious meal!
Be the first to ReplyGreat food and atmsophere
We took the risk of arriving a little later at 8:15pm with out a reservation on a Saturday night and were really lucky to arrive as 2 were leaving from the bar.
Itโs a small restaurant with about 8 seats at the bar as well - I say bar but itโs more overlooking the kitchen area which is fast and furious! The restaurant is noisy but this provides for a great atmosphere- just donโt go for a quiet romantic meal!
The menu isnโt vast but there are daily specials too. We chose mainly from the menu.
Food was great - I had the fried squid appetiser which, with the sublime salad and dressing, a real stand out dish. For our mains I had the soft shelled crab on the specials board and y wife the shrimp burger. Both were really tasty and well cooked.
We felt a little full for a dessert so shared a hot fudge sundae which was a good choice.
Service was friendly and efficient all night.
Great place to lunch in The Village
Myself and my sister visited in May whilst visiting NYC from the UK. We really enjoyed the food, reasonably priced. Very nice staff. Liked the vibe. Best crab I have ever tasted. Highly recommend, excellent. Loved it!!
Be the first to Reply